As John Wycliffe and the Court of Owls continues to indoctrinate Sarah Washington even more, Talon and Casey's agents continue to search for the little girl all over Gotham, where they believe the Court of Owls may be binding, to no luck. Elsewhere, Sebastian Clarke and Felix Harmon take the old Harbor House as their own, planning an attack on the Court of Owls, who are hiding in the old Orchard Hotel.
Casey, who is pretty smart, tells Calvin to look at the Orchard Hotel, but Calvin believes their "Eden" base to be sealed off, and for whatever reason, thinks there's no way to get oxygen to it.... uuuh. But regardless, Casey insists, so Anya and Joey go off to search Amusement Mile, Edgar stays behind to guard Casey, and Calvin finally goes to the hotel, but not before telling Casey that he loves her and promising to get Sarah back.
Inside the hotel, John Wycliffe comes to find many members of the Court slaughtered, and begins to panic, but then Calvin shows up, demanding to know where Sarah is. John begs him to stop before he shows up, but Calvin is only interested in Sarah, who makes an appearance, being held by Felix Harmon.
Calvin gets Felix to let Sarah go, by baiting him into a fight, and as they do, Casey notices Calvin's signal getting lost, so she knows she was right about the Hotel, and calls in her agents, meanwhile, Sebastian sets up a bomb to blow the hotel sky-high.
On his way through the hotel, Sebastian comes across a wounded Wycliffe, and puts a bullet between his eyes, thus resuming his role as Grandmaster of the Court. Soon after that, Sebastian finds Sarah, who has seemingly become indoctrinated and tells him that she wants to kill Calvin herself.
Calvin's fight against Felix is going pretty poorly, and they're eventually surrounded by a good number of Talons, but Sebastian shows up, claiming to be their grandmaster again. As Felix has Calvin pinned to the ground, he starts to inject him with the serum that deteriorates Talons flesh, but there's a giant explosion, and Casey (robot arm and all) has shown up with her agents, and are ready for a fight.